Neal met up with fellow Steelers blogger Jay from The Blitzburgh Report again for another email exchange. Jay’s revamped his web site, and the design is really cool, so you should check it out. In the meantime, Jay and Neal get into J-Peezy’s return, more thoughts on the Steelers offensive line and the possibility of Miami scoring an upset tonight.
Neal: Just think, Jay, in just a few hours, we get to see J-Peezy stalking around the 45 yard line barking at his former teammates.What do you think their reactions will be? Will Larry Foote go after him? Hines, even? You don’t think he’d be gutsy enough to prance through their warm-up lines like Warren Sapp did back in 2002, do you?Cuz that was really lame… I can’t help but think Porter will do something upon his return to Heinz Field. Not so much anything of value in the game, mind you, but something before it, something trying to really get under the skin of the Steelers. Maybe moon them?
Jay: I would have thought in the past that the Joey would do something to leave his mark, but I think he will be quiet tonight. Anything that I have read from him this season seems to indicate that he is quite humbled with regards to the Steelers and how poorly he and his new team are doing. It is a bit sad, in a way, but I think Joey has got to miss his old teammates and will probably be pretty friendly. I might even expect one good play by Joey. Nothing special, maybe a tackle for a loss, heck, maybe even a sack. That’s all. Something either earlier, or late after the game is already decided. But youknow what, I’ll smile (as long as it doesn’t come at a bad time). He’ll probably do his “boot” and I’ll say farewell.
I’ve got nothing against the guy, but it does go to show you once again that the Steelers know when to hold ‘em and when to fold ‘em. They’ve got a darn good track record of knowing the right time to cut ties.
Although, that just leaves the 400 lbs elephant in the room with Alan Faneca. The offensive line has been horrible as of late, and King Alan isn’t the worst of the bunch, but he’s not playing great either.
Is it right for the Steelers to (seemingly) be passing on re-signing Faneca for big bucks, especially with the line how it is?
Neal: Well, here’s the thing with that. I’ll start by fully admitting this is very much apples to oranges, but Porter’s situation is no different than Big Al’s, in the sense that he’s a veteran, wanting one more big contract with a fortune of guaranteed money.Someone will give it to him, but name me the last Steeler they’ve let go into free agency who has amounted to more than Jack Squat? Plaxico Burress, maybe? Great, he got his financial windfall, and has led the Giants to zero playoff wins, and the Steelers won the Super Bowl the year after he left.
Mike Vrabel, maybe? I might give you Vrabel, maybe even Carlos Emmons, who had a mildly successful career in New York before injuries knocked him down. Was Vrabel better than Porter in their hey-days? No. Was Emmons better than Clark Haggans? Eh…debatable both ways. What about Kendrell Bell? Or Jason Gildon? Or Amos Zereoue? Earl Holmes?
The point is, the Steelers have a laundry list of players they’ve let go, gambling that they didn’t need them, and have been right. There are very few they have let go and those players even went on to decent careers somewhere else. More importantly, there have been a few big examples of players they gave big extensions to, but ended up eating cap space more than anything - Kordell Stewart, Joel Steed, Lee Flowers, etc.
Faneca has been a great player, and it’s possible he’s a Hall of Famer. But c’mon now…he wants $8 million a year! We found Faneca late in the first round. He’s a great player, but I have absolutely no doubt in Kevin Colbert’s ability to find a comparable player for a considerably smaller price tag.
Is that the way the wind is blowing for the off-season, do you think? Looking to draft offensive line pretty high? They have dipped into the
free agent market for offensive linemen with a modicum of success over the years. What do you think they’ll want to do?
Jason: I agree, Faneca will get paid big money, just not by the Steelers. With him gone, the line is going to need a lot of work. Even if they re-signed him it would need a lot of work. So that leaves free agency and the draft. It will be interesting to see just what position they target, however.In my opinion, Sean Mahan doesn’t cut it at center. I’d expect the team to move him back over to guard after the season. The team seemed really high on Darnell Stapleton when they thought enough of him to keep him on the 53 man roster. Kendall Simmons also received an extension to start this season, so obviously he figures into the team’s future plans. Could they possibly swap Mahan and Simmons? The difficultly is that Mahan presumably beat out Simmons, Stapleton, and Marvin Philip at center; so if he is the best of the bunch… yikes.
I’ll have to admit, just thinking about fixing the offensive line makes my head spin. Aside from Marvel Smith, there just aren’t any proven commodities in the bunch and even he hasn’t played his best lately. When I look at the offensive line roster, all I see are a bunch of question marks.
But that is enough talk about what to do with the line after the season is done. Right now the team is in the thick of things and they need better line play A.S.A.P. What do you think can be done right now to help the protection situation?
Neal: Coach Tomlin has said it over and again, effective pass and run blocking does not come down to one lineman, nor does it come down to just the offensive line. Roethlisberger knows he can do a lot of damage to a defense (and probably to himself at some point) if he can buy himself extra time. Because of that, I think he waits perhaps two seconds too long to make a decision, and waits for the rush to come to him, instead of getting rid of the ball before he has to move around.I wouldn’t say this is deliberate as much as it is confidence. At the very least, we’ve seen him to not force passes anymore. I don’t believe the line is the overall problem with the amount of sacks he’s taken; I think a lot of it is he’s trying to buy himself time, and sometimes just can’t get away.
This may sound too simple, but the fact that teams are blitzing up the middle successfully is because Pittsburgh is letting them. How I mean that is the pressure is coming, and instead of checking down, or finding the hot receiver, Ben is scrambling to get away from the initial rush. Very often, he is escaping that first wave, but by that point, he’s lost place of where the receivers are, and can’t find anyone short. It’s a cause-and-effect relationship - they blitz, Ben doesn’t make them pay for it, a la Manning or Brady.
Quick tangent, New England’s offensive line is overrated. May the Boston Extremists find me and de-limb me, but I have seen both Light and Kaczur give up a few monster sacks. Brady is able to mask it largely because he knows when to get rid of the ball, and largely because the lethal 3-WR set they have makes it tough to blitz.
Think of it that way, if Ben was able (willing?) to throw quick, precision routes at a high rate of success, all right into the places of the blitzing LBs, how easy is it going to be to blitz him?
The fact is, he doesn’t. He’s always looking well down the field. He gets away with it, but as we saw last weekend, if he isn’t getting away with it, Pittsburgh is a beatable team.
So is Miami, though, and I’m not sure they are able to leave their CBs on an island, even without Santonio Holmes in there. How big of a game could Nate Washington potentially have? I mean, he is pretty much the embodiment of Featherstone from Necessary Roughness (fast as all get-out, nearly-humorous bad hands…he’s the Ike Taylor of the offense), but all he has to do is catch it most of the time. I gotta like his chances against someone like Hopkins High School’s Mike Lehan (only I would name-drop one of the least valuable defensive backs in the NFL, but I tackled Lehan a few times. He hit a home run off me, too).
Jason: I think Nate should do pretty well tonight. It is getting to the point with him that he needs to show he can perform or it is time to look elsewhere. Maybe you have some inside information on Mike Lehan that we can fax over to Nate before game time.I expect the Steelers to win big tonight. Mind you, that is not a prediction, but an expectation. They have been flat against weaker opponents, barely escaped in a close Browns game, and lost to the Jets last week. This team needs to desperately prove itself right here and now. They’ve had a lot of trouble matching the intensity of teams that came out ready to hit them in the mouth, but if they don’t come into this game looking to absolutely destroy the Dolphins then they have major problems. They have so much to prove that I will be very shocked if they come out flat.
Last Monday night game against the Ravens was a real treat, and I expect the same this time. I’ve got my work done and out of the way, my towel ready, and some beer all set to go. I expect another enjoyable game here tonight. If it is not, then we are going to know that this team likely isn’t going as far as we thought a few weeks ago.
Neal: Inside scoop on Lehan: Not a playmaker, doesn’t tackle all that well, doesn’t turn and run particularly well…not even really sure how he starts, but he is on a pretty thin team, defensively. Other than that, I’m sure he does a helluva job.That’s good insight. Stat of Concern…the Steelers are 1-2 this season when playing the league’s 32nd-ranked rush defense (lost to Denver and New York, win over Cleveland in their second meeting).